diff --git a/app/javascript/mastodon/reducers/timelines.js b/app/javascript/mastodon/reducers/timelines.js
index 301997567..53a644e47 100644
--- a/app/javascript/mastodon/reducers/timelines.js
+++ b/app/javascript/mastodon/reducers/timelines.js
@@ -66,13 +66,22 @@ const expandNormalizedTimeline = (state, timeline, statuses, next, isPartial, is
 
         // Then, try to find the furthest (if properly sorted, oldest) item in the timeline that
         // is newer than the most recent fetched one, as it delimits a section comprised of only
-        // items present in `newIds` (or that were deleted from the server, so should be removed
+        // items older or within `newIds` (or that were deleted from the server, so should be removed
         // anyway).
         // Stop the gap *after* that item.
         const firstIndex = oldIds.take(lastIndex).findLastIndex(id => id !== null && compareId(id, newIds.first()) > 0) + 1;
 
-        // Make sure we aren't inserting duplicates
-        let insertedIds = ImmutableOrderedSet(newIds).subtract(oldIds.take(firstIndex), oldIds.skip(lastIndex)).toList();
+        let insertedIds = ImmutableOrderedSet(newIds).withMutations(insertedIds => {
+          // It is possible, though unlikely, that the slice we are replacing contains items older
+          // than the elements we got from the API. Get them and add them back at the back of the
+          // slice.
+          const olderIds = oldIds.slice(firstIndex, lastIndex).filter(id => id !== null && compareId(id, newIds.last()) < 0);
+          insertedIds.union(olderIds);
+
+          // Make sure we aren't inserting duplicates
+          insertedIds.subtract(oldIds.take(firstIndex), oldIds.skip(lastIndex));
+        }).toList();
+
         // Finally, insert a gap marker if the data is marked as partial by the server
         if (isPartial && (firstIndex === 0 || oldIds.get(firstIndex - 1) !== null)) {
           insertedIds = insertedIds.unshift(null);